At the October Synod and Revive gathering of the ACNA’s Upper Midwest Diocese, Bishop Eric Menees of San Joaquin preached. His sermon was a tone-deaf illustration of everything wrong with ACNA, because he opened it with an extravagant apology to Bishop Stewart Ruch:
I know you know this already, but in Bishop Stewart, you have a man of incredible grace and talent and leadership. He is a person who over the last several years has embodied discipline, and integrity, and love, and faith. He and Katherine…and their families have been so deeply aggrieved and wounded and harmed.
And I want to say before I open the Word to you: I’m sorry. I’m sorry that the church treated them, and by extension you, so poorly. And yet you, the Upper Midwest Diocese, have responded with such grace and such love.
But friends, I want to say I’m sorry. I failed you. As a bishop in Christ’s one, holy, catholic, and apostolic Church, I failed you. When we say the confession, we pray for those things done and left undone. And myself and the entire College of Bishops, year after year after year saying, “Oh, it’s not going to go there, it’s not going to go there, no surely this will be…” And we were silent, and I was silent. And I beg your forgiveness.
And I pray that you will not allow the evil one to plant seeds of bitterness or resentment. I pray that you will not turn inward and say, “We’re just going to isolate ourselves and be by ourselves.” I pray that you will do everything that Revive has been about: to be a blessing to others. Mark my words: in the not-too-distant future, the Lord will restore this diocese fourfold and more. And he will make you a light to the rest of this province. And you will be sending out missionaries throughout this province to say, “This is what Jesus is about. This is who we are as Christians in the Anglican tradition.” And so I beg your forgiveness. And I pray that you will pray for me and the College of Bishops as we seek to move forward and try to live a more godly way. And so Bishop Stewart and Katherine, I’m sorry.
This is not his first attempt to defend Ruch. At some point in 2022 Menees was part of a Zoom call with Bishop Ruch, Bishop Lowenfield, Bishop Reed, and Bishop Atwood which resulted in “a demand for investigation of rumor and innuendo that Bishop Stewart submitted to Archbishop Foley Beach on October 13, 2022.” Menees said of Ruch: “There was a long period of silence, and I kept reaching out to the archbishop to say, you need to reach out to him. Pastorally, he’s sinking here. He’s falling into a depression. He’s been isolated and alone. You need to reach out to him. And I know that others were saying the same thing.”
This was around the same time that the Washington Post reports:
…on June 9, 2022, at St. John’s Abbey Guesthouse, northwest of Minneapolis, (Josh) Moon entered her room uninvited after the two hung out by a lake along the property, she said. He put his hand on her back under her shirt and below her waist. Then, he tried to kiss her, and she stopped him.
Days later, J.A., who is also married, reported the incident to Ruch and two other church officials, she said. Despite his leave of absence, Ruch weighed in, chastising her for being alone with Moon in any setting, according to her interview and a letter she wrote to the then-archbishop. He offered her a prayer of absolution for her “sin,” she said.
“It was absolutely manipulative,” J.A. said. “What Bishop Ruch should have told me in that moment was that Josh had a criminal history and, ‘I’m so sorry — you were sexually assaulted.’”
Bishop Ruch barred this assault victim from speaking publicly about her disciplinary process. My theory is that he knew her speaking in public about him would have torpedoed his already shaky hold on power, because the public both then and now has not registered the Moon accusations, instead focusing (understandably) on the Mark Rivera horrors.
The trial of Bishop Ruch exonerated him, Bishop Menees is now apologizing to him, and we can look forward to his leadership in ACNA for years to come!

Leave a Reply